Podcast Transcript

Is the Metaverse Dead?

Christoph Sitar Owner & CEO, MEDIASQUAD

Christoph Sitar owns MEDIASQUAD, an award-winning XR studio in Tirol building multi-user mixed-reality experiences. A conversation about what survived the metaverse hype, and where AR and VR actually deliver.

  • Published 28 Oct 2024
  • Runtime 51:25
  • Operator
  • Recorded in English
Is the Metaverse Dead?: podcast episode with Christoph Sitar, Owner & CEO, MEDIASQUAD
// The short version
  • Christoph Sitar, Owner and CEO of MEDIASQUAD, rejects the original single-world metaverse vision, at least for now. He describes continued development of interconnected virtual worlds and mixed reality, comparing the underlying infrastructure to the internet’s base layer.
  • Sitar reports a strong sense of presence even with abstract robot avatars. MEDIASQUAD’s framework, built on Meta’s Shared Spatial Anchors, uses accurately tracked hands, and he describes users fist-bumping and high-fiving people who are not physically in the room.
  • According to Sitar, hand tracking was the breakthrough for non-gamers: people can grab, push buttons, and interact the way they expect without learning a controller first.
  • In the episode published on October 28, 2024, Sitar calls Zuckerberg’s glasses demo close to an iPhone moment. He conditionally reserves that label for consumer-ready delivery about two years later at roughly 1,500 dollars; the iPhone, he notes, was already a consumer product at launch.
  • Both speakers raise privacy concerns about camera glasses and room labeling. Sitar raises hypothetical profiling, targeted advertising and insurance-pricing risks, and hopes policymakers regulate before these become an issue, without stifling innovation.

Is the Metaverse Dead?

Watch this part · 0:00

Kevin 0:00 Hi everyone, welcome at Wavect. Today we’re going to talk with Christoph Sitar. He’s the owner of MEDIASQUAD, an XR, VR, AR software agency and they’re doing crazy stuff, really. They’ve won a lot of awards for what they’re doing and they do it incredibly well. So I’m really pleased to have Christoph on today and we’re going to talk about all sorts of things from data privacy issues when it comes to mixed reality or all the innovations that are happening right now in the space, like all the new headsets and like everything that’s coming up right now and business use cases and everything.

Kevin 0:43 Like really stay tuned. It’s really exciting. And [unclear] can’t wait anymore. So let’s dive in.

0:50 Wavect, the Web3 software company that understands what you want.

Kevin 0:56 Is the metaverse dead or not?

Christoph 1:02 Well, you’re asking me as a VR enthusiast, so I’d say no, it’s not dead. It definitely changed. You know, when it first was coined, when Meta, now Meta, became Meta from being Facebook, then I think people were thinking about this interconnected Ready Player One world. They were thinking we would all dive into there.

Christoph 1:30 We would not do any Teams calls anymore. Maybe we wouldn’t even love and kiss in the real world anymore. Everything would be virtual. The metaverse is definitely not that. So it kind of evolved. There’s a lot of work being done in the background ever since that point. People, companies are putting together base layers on what it means to create interconnected virtual worlds.

Christoph 1:57 There’s also the part of the metaverse where virtual content gets injected into our everyday lives. And in terms of mixed reality content, being part of our actual reality but enhances it. It can be easy things like directions in cars, can be complex things like sharing virtual content between a couple of people who have those glasses on.

Christoph 2:24 You know, most likely everybody has seen the Apple Vision Pro, has seen the Meta Quest 3, those VR glasses that are really good at actually showing your physical world, but then putting some augmentations in there. And then connecting people who, for example, you being far away, you have the glasses on, me being here, my friend staying right next with me here, and we all share that same virtual content between us and can even give stuff, interact with stuff with each other over the distance or right there.

Christoph 3:00 So to answer the question, I think the first vision of a metaverse, like this one world where everybody dives in, I think that is not going to happen. Like with the internet back in the day, it never was just one website. It was a base of a base layer, a protocol that enables people to create multiple websites, multiple verses in the metaverse.

Christoph 3:34 So I think it evolved and I think it’s, it’s there, getting slowly into a place where it’s, where it’s going to be usable for a majority of people in the very near future.

Kevin 3:51 Very interesting take. So from my understanding, you don’t really believe that social aspect of the metaverse, that social metaverse, as people call it, is going to be something, or a thing?

Is the Social Metaverse a Thing?

Watch this part · 3:55

Christoph 4:08 Again, not in the same way as it was advertised. I mean, I spent myself a lot of times because I’m 42, I have two kids and I don’t have that much time. So when I want to play Dungeons and Dragons, all the peers that I used to play with, nobody has time anymore. They all also have kids. So I delve into, for example, Demeo.

Christoph 4:30 I play with other people in this small multiplayer game, but that could also be kind of like a social metaverse. I spend a lot of time in Altspace during COVID when it was still a thing. Was acquired by Microsoft and then silently, well, snuffed out. But I really enjoyed that aspect. I really like to mingle with people.

Christoph 4:54 I like the conversations I had there. And I think that is definitely going to be something in the future, but it has to offer some kind of consistency. You have to have your own persona between multiple worlds. And before that base layer is established in a meaningful way, I think NFTs could be the base layer for, you know, on a technical point of view, having my own persona and stats rendered into that persona and then being used in different kinds of metaverses.

Christoph 5:30 So I think that’s going to be a thing. What I also saw is things like Fortnite exploding, exploding. They have concerts, they have, they have really famous acts playing concerts in there, people, crowds cheering through it. I’ve seen Roblox really, really getting traction. It’s so interesting. It’s so amazing.

Christoph 5:51 I don’t think it’s for my generation 40 plus, you know, definitely not a lot of people delve into that. But my friend’s kid, 12 years old now, he’s all into the Gorilla Tag, into the Roblox, into the Fortnite. And for them it is very much a reality, spending time with your friends on the actual basketball court or spending it chasing each other with a Gorilla Tag session.

Kevin 6:17 Interesting. Yeah, well, as you said yourself, it’s definitely going to be a generational thing, right? People spend their time differently depending on the generation.

Christoph 6:31 Like, as the metaverse evolves. Yeah, I think there’s also a need for our generation, but it has to be kind of different. I think you already tried the Apple Vision Pro and that personas feature, right, where first you scan your head and then Apple creates automatically this physical persona of yourself and puts it on an avatar.

Christoph 6:59 And because Apple tracks your facial patterns, it tracks your eyes. So basically the person that you interact with has kind of like a hologram, a little bit like Star Wars, only a little bit better, but then also not, it’s not there yet, but has a little hologram of you sitting right next to them. And that is something, think of families living far apart.

Christoph 7:27 Think of the United States. Everybody moves around all the time. Having your mom, having your grandma in the place where you can actually look them in the eye, where you can actually talk to them, not via video call, but via something that feels more realistic, I think that is going to be definitely something also for the older generation too.

Kevin 7:58 A very interesting point, um. Could it be, and that’s maybe food for thought, that what you just described, for example that, uh, use case, okay, family, uh, quite apart, that this could be an intermediary solution? And one final pos, like one possibility of where we might end up to is where we actually have something like really human-like robots in the real world that people, like on the other end of the world, can actually in real time, you know, move and these kind of things.

Is Mixed Reality just the Start?

Watch this part · 8:00

Kevin 8:41 Like I’m just thinking really abstract here and trying to make sense, because from, from a use case perspective you said, okay, well, I have people I love next to me, right? And of course if they’re actually here in some sense I can touch them, that’s different, right? So it’s actually better, maybe.

Kevin 9:04 So just, uh, [unclear].

Christoph 9:07 Okay, I have a couple of thoughts on that, actually, also from what we, what we did over the last couple months, um, for your, for your viewers, for your listeners. We developed, uh, based on a technology from Meta called, uh, Shared Spatial Anchors, uh, basically we developed, uh, on top of that a, a framework where, again, I mentioned this in the beginning, a couple of people in the same room have the headset on.

Christoph 9:34 They see the real world. They share kind of a hologram. So you would see it from this side. I would see it from that side. My friend would see it from here. I can interact with the stuff. I can give it away. But it’s also possible to get people from externally there. Now, the way we do this, we don’t try to, you know, put real faces on.

Christoph 9:57 The uncanny valley, where it is kind of weird, is too much of a, too much of an issue there. So we go super abstract, like a robot. Hands, robot. But the hands, they’re already super, super accurately tracked. So every movement, if I, if I go like this, if I go like this, everything is super accurately tracked.

Christoph 10:17 So why do I mention that? Because with that framework, we very regularly have sessions with clients where we test out from location A, location B, five people at location A, two people at location B, and then we let them interconnect and interact. Now what is interesting, because you said that physical thing is missing: I’ve had people who actually go fist bump and high five themselves after a session, like yeah, and with someone who isn’t there, who has no physical thing, but it felt, and, and with a robot head, like, you know, it’s just a face shield with Japanese manga eyes.

Kevin 11:00 I see, I see.

Christoph 11:00 Doesn’t matter. People get so, because they hear the voice from that direction, they hear, they see the acting, like if I move my hands, that all feels so natural because all the finger movement is there, that they start fist bumping, they start interacting, they start giving stuff. And what I got as feedback, and this is actual things that I do, uh, it’s part of my job, so I, I really experience that a lot of times, is: it felt like there was someone there.

Christoph 11:32 And then you put, uh, put those glasses off your head and then suddenly a person is gone. It is weird and that’s what I heard. So now come think a little, one generation, maybe two generations further on where it’s not just a face shield anymore, but where it is an actual person, you know, being transported in your space, into your space, interacting with you.

Christoph 11:58 And if for example, I hand you the key and the other person picks it up, although the person’s not not there, but it’s visually there and takes the virtual key away from you. Now, that’s something that’s already solved. That’s actually a thing. And this feels so realistic already. Think one, two generations further on, and we do have a social metaverse, a social connectedness that is, of course, not the real world, but very, very close to having, or the next best thing to having your people around you.

Kevin 12:42 Fist bumping. Now, that’s something like, I think when I tested out your software myself a while ago, That’s something I completely forgot, right? Because that feedback you get, right? That sensation when you actually fist bump or something, that’s actually something I could imagine is underrated, right?

Fist Bumping and Remote Feedback

Watch this part · 12:45

Kevin 13:04 From like we have all these online offerings, especially when you go to psychologists and all sorts of things, right? This [unclear] partially maybe done that way or improved that way without being required to actually visit that place, right? So that’s, that’s another cool...

Christoph 13:27 Interesting that you say psychologists, maybe linguists, maybe even teachers for some aspects. There’s also an aspect that really surprised me. My parents, they’re both not gamers, absolutely not. They’re the generation that give them Tatort, which is an Austrian detective series, and at quarter past 8 at night.

Christoph 13:56 And they will be extremely happy just watching TV, hanging around and having a good time with classic media. And my mom then, I put her on this motorbike that we built in mixed reality. And what she said was, and it was really weird for me, she was standing there, she was gripping it, she was moving it and she said, 'I feel, I can feel it.

Christoph 14:23 I’m sitting there. Did you put a chair? Is it there?' I was like, 'No, Mom, you’re just, you’re, you’re imagining it because it is, for you it’s real.' So in her mind, the visuality and the possibility to interact with the real and with the virtual stuff in the real world was akin to stimulating something that induces feeling the thing although it’s not there.

Christoph 14:53 And that was really weird. I’ve had this sensation, a couple of people told me about that, that they can kind of feel something, although nothing’s there. But with her, I was really surprised, because she’s absolutely not the target group that I usually cater to.

Kevin 15:12 Well, I mean, I’m pretty sure you know this experiment, right, where you have like a separator between your two arms.

Christoph 15:19 Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Kevin 15:21 And then [unclear] on the arm. Yeah, I mean that, that’s exact, that’s actually proof, proof that this must be like possible, right? Like if the, like feedback from the software, from the framework and, uh, the overall sensations are sufficient that you actually believe this is true.

Kevin 15:46 And this brings me to a lot of very interesting conclusions, right? You could use that actually in therapy, in retirement homes. Just think about that. Like you’re actually too old for a lot of things, but you could still do skydiving. Wow, that’s kind of cool. Well, I would get sick, of course, because I do get motion sick sometimes, you know.

Kevin 16:14 Just an example. Maybe that’s a solvable problem. I don’t know. But yeah, I could definitely imagine that this results in a lot of good stuff.

Christoph 16:25 I mean, there’s an expert that I follow closely on LinkedIn, Professor Bob Stone. He’s been in VR ever since, I don’t know, 1986, something like that. When I was still an infant, he already played around with that things. He’s actually utilizing the power of the virtual worlds and mixed reality worlds in the context of retirement homes therapy, getting people to do experiences that they can’t do anymore.

Christoph 16:55 So yeah, that has been done and I think we’re making great progress on that. Also especially with the hardware being ever developed further and further. It’s funny, sometimes I hear VR is dead or XR is dead or mixed reality is dead. And people sometimes like to quote because the Google glasses didn’t work.

Christoph 17:20 And I’m like, okay. It’s like telling me that, I don’t know, TV is dead because back in the 60s someone failed to do an experiment. So what I see right now is those devices, they get smaller, those devices, they get sharper with the technology that’s there and those devices, they are easier to interact with.

Christoph 17:46 Think a couple of years back, the biggest, the biggest revolution for me was actually hand tracking because whenever I put a controller into one of my clients' hands, and we do a lot of B2C stuff, um, so you have the, the average Joe, the average shop floor worker, you know, they, they’re not gamers.

Christoph 18:07 I’ve heard people tell me, you know, uh, just so you know that my kid always spends time on that damn PlayStation and I hate it, so I don’t like the computer games. And some, some people going like that, and I’m like, okay, I understand, I dig that. It’s not a computer game. It’s different. It just, it is kind of like real.

Christoph 18:31 And then they had to learn that controller and they were, it was hard for them. And now we have hand tracking, we have facial recognition, face tracking. And suddenly people can actually interact, grab, do push buttons, and it behaves the way they think it should. They don’t have to learn everything anew.

Christoph 18:51 Oh man, that is powerful. And now combine that with next-gen glasses. I don’t know if you’ve seen the recent Facebook Connect keynote that Mark Zuckerberg gave, you know, Meta, the really...

Meta’s new Glasses

Watch this part · 19:00

19:09 Oh man, yeah, almost regular-looking glasses. You mean the, the...

Christoph 19:14 So for your, for your audience, Mark Zuckerberg, one of the richest people in the world who spends more than 10 billion US dollars, so 10 Milliarden Euro, every single year on the development of his version, vision of the metaverse, which also includes the hardware. He’s on stage and he puts on glasses, actual glasses.

Christoph 19:39 They’re big, thick rimmed. I mean, not a most fashionable item, but also they were kind of cool looking. I mean, yeah. The key thing, the key takeaway was it was actual glasses. And they are not just, you know, they cannot just produce a little bit of frame or image or a video picture. No, they have actual depth, depth hologramic capabilities.

Christoph 20:09 So in front of me right there, I could have this pen rotating and it would feel to me like it’s there and I could grab it because of course he has the hand grabbing, hand interaction algorithms. Could grab it. Then I could play with it. I could open it. Maybe I can click on it, change the color, and then you wear those glasses.

Christoph 20:31 You’re sitting right there and I can hand you those and you can pick them up and you can do that. He actually showcased, uh, playing a Pong game, you know, where a ball goes, uh, between two players and they’re like ch, chu, ch, ch, ch. And the, the big, biggest thing was he could see it with his own eyes through an actual lens instead of a video camera.

Christoph 20:56 And the device wasn’t big, it wasn’t small, it was just glasses. Now that is a revolution that’s not going to happen next year. He says two years, maybe three years until he has that price and the hardware, the manufacturing down to something akin of an iPhone from a cost perspective. But imagine that.

Christoph 21:23 Imagine I’m in Spain and I don’t speak Spanish and I have those glasses on and they can immediately translate stuff for me. And I basically hear out of the phones in the glasses, I hear the person that’s talking to me in my own language and vice versa. Imagine going into a hardware store, buying new furniture for your office.

Christoph 21:53 And instead of that, the guy comes, maybe the sales rep comes to you, hands you those glasses or you already have them. You just open that app and you basically go around your office, you look around, you look around, and then you activate the AI agent. And you tell him, hey, that office, because what it does, those glasses, they are meshing, they’re measuring the room that you’re into.

Christoph 22:16 Oh, by the way, sorry, that one interesting part for your audience. I love that feature. I couldn’t believe it when I first saw it. The Quest 3 from Meta, it already does that. It’s looking at my room and then suddenly outlines appear and this says window, table, table, chair, door, cupboard. Man, it already recognizes what it sees and can label it.

Christoph 22:48 And now imagine having those small glasses do that, measure everything, know the room, and then I’m activating the AI agent. And I say, hey, I would like to have six workspaces here. Yeah, that looks kind of cool. No, now I want in groups of four and one group of two. And then suddenly I see the new layout.

Christoph 23:10 Hey, you know what? I want it in the anthracite color. And please give me, I don’t know, oak for the surface. OK, that looks good. What’s the quote on that? And because it’s already querying all that data and putting it in there, it can give me a quote that basically floats there. This, this item costs $200, this costs a thousand, this costs 500.

Christoph 23:37 I think that’s going to be the reality, combining the AI part with that mixed reality or AR part, so augmented reality and, uh, and, and, and AI, uh, uh, artificial intelligence and having that on the tip of your glasses without looking weird. Man, that’s going to be great. And it’s not far away.

Christoph 24:03 The tech, most of the tech, I’d say 80% is already there. Sorry, that was long, but I get a little enthusiastic at points.

Kevin 24:15 Very interesting, Christoph.

Christoph 24:17 I would consider myself being one of the foremost Austrian VR, XR experts. And right now with my company MEDIASQUAD, we focus mostly on making that mixed reality come true in a context where you have a couple of people together, they share virtual content in the real world while having fun and while being really, really easy to interact with.

Kevin 24:44 I mean, have you seen that, not sure if it was an experiment by, I think Harvard students where they basically also put, was, I’m not sure if it was the Meta glasses or something else just recently, but they were able to, by just looking at you, get all your information from public data sources. Like that’s Christoph, he owns that company, that’s his sister, mom and so on and so forth just by walking by, right?

Data Privacy Issues with Mixed Reality

Watch this part · 24:50

Kevin 25:17 Um, of course that’s maybe a use case people are not comfortable with, um. Um, but this just leads me to, I mean, that, that’s the last thing that from, from a data source perspective that you need to really have the full world, like everything we see in the digital world, right? When you, basically when you have that labeling happening, uh, in your private room, Meta or whoever knows, like can create stats, right, in an anonymous fashion hopefully, say, hey, okay, our room does look like this and based on that you can or you should create, uh, let’s say lamps that look like this, right,

Kevin 26:07 because people would buy it, whatever. What are you thinking about, like all of that implications? Where do you see all that going?

Christoph 26:17 I think from a privacy point of view, we can’t even imagine how the world will change with these kinds of technologies. I mean, think about those Ray-Ban glasses. You know that Meta has already released a cooperation with Ray-Ban. All they do is they can do a little bit of AI stuff now and in the next generation.

Christoph 26:37 And you can listen to stuff, but you can film stuff. Of course, all the people in those, well, nude zones, you can’t go in there with any kind of Ray-Ban anymore. No, but what happened, and this was kind of like a little bit of an outlook. Did you hear about that Italian minister for culture who had an affair with an Italian influencer?

Christoph 27:05 And she kind of blackmailed him. He had to, of course, resign afterwards. She kind of blackmailed him. And the way that she got proof of what happened, what transpired, was she actually had those Ray-Bans on, and she filmed that. So it was pretty crazy. Nobody in that circle knew what the tech was. And of course, it should have a little red dot going, but you can easily paint it, paint over it.

Christoph 27:35 So what’s happening there already is if nothing is private anymore, if everything is labeled, if everything is categorized, then privacy will be a big issue. First time, and this was a couple years back now, where inside-out tracking, so basically the headset you put it on and it tracks your environment for you, was introduced by major headset manufacturers.

Christoph 28:03 I was laughing and I thought, okay, let’s wait. Let’s put, I don’t know, a fake rifle on the table. You know, one of those, one of those fakes and see if the police will come by later today. You don’t know what will happen, you know, and especially with AI, if everything that you film is being analyzed the second you walk around with that, man, then you don’t need people looking at that.

Christoph 28:35 But then you see, I don’t know, a gun there, a [unclear] there, maybe something illegal there. Suddenly your insurance goes up because in your own room. Maybe you get an ad for a new TV because it recognizes you still have one of the old, you know, smaller TVs. Maybe you get different kinds of offers for all kinds of things based on the environment that you lived in.

Christoph 29:03 I don’t want to see that happen. I really hope that policymakers, that politicians of all kinds of sorts, without stifling innovation, will be able to regulate that before it becomes an issue. And also what I do not want to see, I do not want to have a third of these glasses, of that area, always being bombarded with AdWords or something.

Christoph 29:32 And the way Netflix, Prime, everything is going now, they rediscovered ads. I mean, think how crazy that is. We had regular TV, people started pirating because they hated the ads of regular TV. And in the US, it was unbearable. You know, pirating, out of pirating they develop business models that really got them, made them a ton of, a shitload of money more than they ever had before, but everything was [unclear], more than they ever had before.

Christoph 30:03 And now suddenly they realize, Hey, ads are a great thing. Everybody likes them. No, nobody likes ads. Sorry. It’s especially not during your, your TV, your engagement. But the thing is, with a TV, you can turn it off. You can look away. You can zap to a different location. Even on the internet, on YouTube, you can just spend those 15 seconds doing something else.

Christoph 30:29 But once it’s in your peripheral vision, once it’s always there, it gets really hard to not notice that, to not be influenced. Think about the power of political messaging, political influence, brainwashing in a kind of way. So I really hope that those people in power are responsible with that technology, are responsible with tracking our behavior, not scheduling us into different sorts of things.

Christoph 31:01 I do want to iterate on that. Because what happened recently, I tried for the first time a couple of new platforms. Something like, I’ve never actually signed up to Reddit, so I don’t have a track record on Reddit. I read lots of articles. I never, I discovered that there is a thing called Scrolller that basically captures stuff from Reddit.

Christoph 31:25 And when you’re new to a platform, any kind of platform, you, the algorithm doesn’t know you yet, so you get a lot of interesting content that you never got before. You know, when I log into YouTube, I will get the same stuff, lots of Pokémon Go, some online stuff, lots of VR stuff, some political news.

Christoph 31:46 And for some reason YouTube believes I really like dancing women bouncing up and down. I have no idea why that is, um. I’m surprised. And then you go to a different platform and suddenly you get interesting stuff again. So just think if those algorithms, they start labeling you for what they think that you want to see.

Christoph 32:10 And then you’re getting even more stuck, stuck, stuck in that instead of having really the diversity of the content that’s out there being delivered to you. So I really hope that there is not going to be too much of labeling us, but still letting us be human beings, curious human beings. I don’t know how they will do it, but they really have to, if we shouldn’t go down the drain.

Kevin 32:43 I mean, that’s a really interesting point, right? But yeah, I mean, the only reason I guess this is not already fully the case right now is because there are privacy laws, right?

32:55 Yeah.

Kevin 32:56 Otherwise we already, even without that tech, just say something next to your smartphone and you get an ad. It’s already. You notice that too? It’s so obvious.

Christoph 33:11 You know, my, a funny thing: back in 2016, suddenly my wife, who was a university professor, got, when she showed the students something, always ads for Clearblue pregnancy tests. And it was exactly that point when we started, you know, trying to, to, to get, uh, family going and it was never before, it was never after.

Christoph 33:41 Google knew that we were trying to, to, to have kids before we knew that we actually wanted to have kids. That was creepy. When it actually goes into human behavior, that’s crazy.

Kevin 33:57 Yeah, it’s like, it’s weird, um, like when there also, like I think it’s already 10, 15 years now, I don’t know, like when Facebook recognized even people being pregnant before they knew. Like I just imagine what they can do now or would do now.

Christoph 34:14 I’m pretty sure they just do, just don’t do a lot of things because that would creep people out. Pretty sure they could do much more. But going back to our topic of the extended reality, I think there’s so much good in there that can actually really enhance the way we interact, also open up tons and tons and tons of new business opportunities, also reduce dramatically our carbon footprint.

Christoph 34:44 Just imagine now all the back to office policies of the big major companies. They all argue because there’s more teamwork going on with that. Just imagine having actual people around your space, not seeing your actual space, if you don’t want to. Maybe that is something you can transport to into a metaverse kind of view.

Christoph 35:07 but having those meaningful interactions by the coffee machine or by the water cooler and really getting to leverage that even over a long distance. Suddenly, we’re back to a more flexible kind of behavior even in a work situation. And I think, again, with what Mark Zuckerberg showed us two weeks ago in his demo, now everything is more tangible.

Christoph 35:35 It’s, it’s, it’s, it has been kind of like right around the corner for a long time, but now it actually feels like it is because this mega tech mogul put those things on his face and showed live footage of what is going to happen and how it works already. So there’s a game changer there. People call it even an iPhone moment.

An iPhone moment for MR, if Meta delivers

Watch this part · 36:00

Christoph 36:01 I do not because the iPhone was already a consumer product when Steve Jobs launched it. It was the one more thing that went out and changed everything. It changed everything. That is close to it. If he really can deliver and in two years' time he has the market ready at a price of, I don’t know, 1500 bucks, it will be an iPhone moment.

Christoph 36:27 It’s interesting that it suddenly, it comes from, from, from Facebook who never was a cool company and Apple actually didn’t deliver that although Apple is supposed to be the cool company, so that was something that was interesting for me too. Even as an Apple fanboy I do have a lot of Apple stuff, really like that, but can also, can also give someone else a win if there is a win to be taken.

Kevin 36:52 Absolutely, absolutely. A lot of crazy things, of course, absolutely coming.

Christoph 36:58 Can I ask you a question for a change, um, how do you see, uh, you know, your technologies, the blockchain-based technologies, interacting or playing a vital role in getting a metaverse going? What is your take on that? Is there a lot of synergies?

Kevin 37:19 And the most boring answer I would give you is monetization, like basically really just, hey, I own that, I can sell it now. Like not all that crazy utility stuff and hype stuff, but I think just having a protocol that allows you to easily, like, have a unified platform infrastructure where you can buy and sell stuff, I think that could be something if it’s scalable enough or if it’s appropriate for the, for the use case.

Christoph 37:51 Will it be blockchain agnostic or interoperable, or will it be a specific blockchain that wins these kinds of things?

Kevin 38:00 I mean, the thing is, the standards are already here, which means if you have an NFT on that blockchain you can transfer it to another in most cases, um, so we already have that protocol kind of standard that you could use here, um. I mean, it’s, it’s definitely like going to be either like a special technology that unifies blockchains, which is kind of fixing their own problems, or it’s just going to be one specific blockchain or a certain set of blockchains that fixes some stuff.

Kevin 38:37 But there are other solutions too, right? Doesn’t need to be a blockchain. Could be just some other protocol or approach as well. But that’s what I could imagine.

Christoph 38:48 Makes sense. Okay, because I definitely see these, I see with, with the metaverse and these technologies coming more and more into, into fruition, I see the need for owning your data, owning your content. I see so many possibilities there, so for me it’s a given. And also the hype has been around since the real hype where lots of people jumped on board, 2017, 2020.

Christoph 39:21 So maybe, and in between, there was a lot of times with the blockchain where there was development, actual development happening under the radar. With our extended reality XR field, we have the similarities. We have the same thing. There was the big hype, you know, when Meta announced the metaverse and everything was crazy going up and, uh, then it became very quiet again but it gave people time to work.

Christoph 39:51 And now suddenly we see those platforms, those products also in, in the, in the teaching kind of positions. There’s a lot of things emerging that are really usable now or getting there, you know, that hype cycle curve. I think we’re being there now. So not in the mainstream, but it will need two more vital things.

Christoph 40:16 It will need some kind of infrastructure where you own your content and it will need the artificial intelligence component where you don’t have to do everything manually, but really utilize the power of AI to put things in there that you want to describe, but you don’t want to put in there painstakingly by hand yourself.

Kevin 40:42 That’s going to be really interesting how this plays out, AI and owning data. Yeah, let’s see. What’s more important to the user? So I feel like it will be like feature, functionality, convenience.

What users want

Watch this part · 40:45

Christoph 41:00 Yeah, because that’s how we are. I think that the reason is also people don’t really grasp what’s happening with the data. Still now, I mean, we have this activist, Max Schrems. He’s an Austrian. And he regularly wins big court cases in front of the European Union against Meta and Google and whoever.

Christoph 41:21 But still, we have those people in the midst, but still the regular Joe doesn’t realize. Even me sometimes, it’s so painstakingly hard to always click on, give me all those options, I do not consent or no cookies or whatever. Sometimes, 5% of the time, I just click, yeah, get the data. You know how it feels.

Christoph 41:47 And then I’m sold already because you see 70 trackers now getting your ID and all your behavior and everything. Now I think that’s, that’s a lot of convenience will play into it. Again politicians will have to make sure that frameworks are in place that actually protect their citizens' interests. It’s gonna be really interesting to see if the politicians in place actually even understand what’s going on there.

Christoph 42:19 I’m not sure with those who are in power now, it doesn’t matter where. I think no politician really grasps it. But I have my hopes up that with the next generation, the actual digital natives coming into those positions of power, they will definitely understand. And I also see that they will even demand because they notice they grew up with the peer pressure of WhatsApp, what, bullying online, grooming, whatever, constant TikTok madness and they will be relieved to not having to go through that all the time.

Christoph 43:00 And they will demand timeouts, breaks, safe spaces even in the visual world, uh, in even in the, in the virtual world. They will demand that. I’m pretty sure about that.

Kevin 43:12 Yeah, uh, like I, I always convince myself that I try, I try to not have opinion on things I have no idea on, um. Let’s see, but I hope so to some extent, um, like I, I just hope that, that it’s not going to be like with data privacy right now where the big ones can do everything they wanna do and the small and medium-sized businesses just struggle with everything, right?

Kevin 43:46 Because that’s oftentimes the consequence. That’s the only remark I would have on that. But let’s see. I mean, is there something like aside from all the really incredible things, Christoph, that you just shared, that you are most excited about personally?

44:13 Personally, in general,

Christoph 44:16 what drives me to do my job and what gets me out of bed is that I see how people who have no affiliation with gaming react to gamified content, and how they, I can just capture them with basic game mechanics and teach them stuff that would usually take longer to teach them, engage them in things that usually wouldn’t be their core interest, and trigger emotions, experiences that they didn’t have before.

Christoph 44:55 And it gets better. The technology is needed for that. There’s a lot of psychological aspects needed, too. There’s a lot of UX, like how the handling works, that needs to be perfected, too, in order for this to work. But I’ll give you one example. I was just at a former client of ours. We did a lot of 3D stuff for them.

Christoph 45:15 They were very reserved with any kind of virtual content. And I contacted them again after not being in touch for a year and contacted them, went with my new framework there and presented that. And suddenly the guy, I recorded the session for them, had a grin on his face the entire time. I never was able to engage these people, show them what the additional benefit of these kinds of technologies is.

Christoph 45:45 And now suddenly I get them, I capture them. I’m able to show them stuff, teach them stuff, enable them to do stuff that they only saw in science fiction movies before that, you know, with this easy kind of interaction that we, that we created. And that is something that excites me the most. That excites me beyond measure.

Christoph 46:10 That brings me to, actually this year I’m a bit proud of that, I was able to, to, ever since February 16 when we launched our framework, I was able to now have, uh, uh, 90, um, one, actually 91 on-site presentations and visits, and February until October 10th.

Christoph 46:35 So, um, and these were fairs, these were clients, these were institutions, these were all kinds of different stakeholders. And I’m doing this because it, with that kind of new technology that’s there, with the mixed reality, I see so much fascination in people’s faces and so many use cases they come up with and so much, yeah, this is what we’ve been waiting for, as a feedback that it actually triggers me to move forward, to go in there and, and, and really, really I can enjoy these kinds of, uh, presentations and interactions as well.

Christoph 47:16 I just love that.

Kevin 47:18 That’s really cool. And use case first, like you have something that actually makes sense, right? And that, that’s always great. If people don’t ask why do I need that, but instead how expensive is it? That’s kind of...

Christoph 47:34 Well, the question about the money is always a thing, but I think that’s, that’s also, uh, [unclear]. It’s a, it’s a thing of our times, you know, but, um, then they also realize, well, it’s even affordable if it has that use case. Just imagine having two engineers in two different locations. And of course, they have their CAD data.

Christoph 47:56 They can always mirror a Teams call. But now they can actually easily have this kind of CAD data in the glasses and discuss it in real time, like they’re standing right next to each other. And they told me, well, this is for them, this is kind of like a game changer, but not because it wasn’t possible before.

Christoph 48:18 It was. If you invested a hundred thousand bucks you could have that even 10 years ago, but nobody wanted to invest 100, 150k for that. Or the people who did, yeah, they got there, they have the reasons why they do, but now you can do it with a fraction of that money and still have a very solid experience that’s even completely agnostic to the, to places, you know.

Christoph 48:46 Outside our window downstairs we do have that courtyard, right? Just for, for, for goofs and giggles I tried getting all the glasses down there. We were still in our Wi-Fi, of course, but I tried to, what happens if we just do it down there, you know, and that was working flawlessly. So what happened was another presentation, one of these 90 presentations, I met with a dude because he was pretty busy at a, at the parking lot of our local Einkaufszentrum, [unclear], shopping center.

Christoph 49:27 At the parking lot, I broke out those two glasses, just tethered them to my phone, gave him the glasses, and we saw each other in there. People started recording us. And I was able to give him the demonstration right there. And then I even looked at one of the bystanders and said, hey, are you good filming us?

Christoph 49:47 They were like, oh, can you see us? Yeah, sure. [unclear]. And it was a weird situation, but it is that flexible. I can just break them out on a parking lot, give a demo, give a presentation. That opens up a world. So is the metaverse dead? I think the initial metaverse, again, it’s at least for now not going to happen.

Christoph 50:14 There’s a lot of developments, but something else that can be called kind of meta visualization, metaverse, meta interaction, meta social interaction is coming in its place and it is already there. And it’s going to be big.

Kevin 50:37 I think that’s a great ending. Thank you, Christoph, for your time. And I personally really enjoyed this and learned a lot from this.

Christoph 50:46 Thank you, Kevin, for having me on your show. And it was really nice interacting the way and talking with an expert on the other side of tech things too, having your opinion on the blockchain part of that triptychon that’s going to be part of our future.

Kevin 51:05 I really learned a lot in this episode. I hope you too. And just leave your feedback in the comments below. Let us know what you think, who we should talk to next. And yeah, thank you for watching.

51:16 Wavect, the Web3 software company that understands what you want.

Transcribed from the original audio with Whisper large-v3 and AI-reconciled with the original automatic captions. Unclear speech is bracketed; speaker labels and translations are editorial aids. No complete human listening pass. The recording remains authoritative; statements reflect its date. This episode was published on October 28, 2024. Hardware timelines, prices and adoption forecasts reflect the discussion at that time. The proposed iPhone moment depends on consumer-ready delivery at the suggested price. The privacy discussion includes personal anecdotes, allegations and hypothetical scenarios.

Questions this episode answers

In the episode published on October 28, 2024, Sitar says the metaverse is not dead. He rejects the single-world vision, at least for now, while describing continued development of interconnected worlds and mixed reality. At the time, he expected it to become usable for a majority of people in the very near future.
Sitar describes mixed reality as virtual content added to actual surroundings, one part of his broader account of the metaverse. He cites Apple Vision Pro and Meta Quest 3 as headsets that show the physical world with augmentations. His shared local and remote interaction example concerns MEDIASQUAD’s framework built on Meta’s Shared Spatial Anchors.
Sitar says controllers were a barrier for non-gamers like shop floor workers in his B2C projects. With hand tracking and face tracking, people can grab objects and push buttons in ways that behave as they expect, so they do not have to learn everything anew. He calls hand tracking the biggest revolution for him.
Kevin recalls an experiment that identified people using glasses and public data sources; he thinks Harvard students were involved and is unsure which glasses were used. Sitar recounts what he describes as an Italian minister’s blackmail affair involving Ray-Ban recordings. Sitar also raises hypothetical risks from room scanning, including profiling, targeted ads and higher insurance costs, and hopes policymakers regulate before these become an issue.
In the episode published on October 28, 2024, Sitar considers Zuckerberg’s Connect demo close to an iPhone moment, but reserves that label because the iPhone was already a consumer product at launch. He says consumer-ready delivery about two years later at roughly 1,500 dollars would be an iPhone moment, conditional on Meta delivering.

Want this kind of thinking applied to your product?

We build MVPs and act as fractional CTOs for founders who’d rather ship than talk.